“my” vs. “mine” in several owner possessive

“my” vs. “mine” in several owner possessive

“We therefore see you delivering my personal and you can Gregg’s man to school now.” – but I would suggest “our kid” or the children’s name could be natural than simply “my personal and Gregg’s son”?

As i go along with Warsaw Usually, wouldn’t it remain grammatically proper to utilize “mine” in this case, if you believe out-of “mine” just like the speaing frankly about “my boy”? That is, let’s say the first phrase is actually it?:

– Ok, but I think Gregg’s son will happen first in one to circumstances and make clear just what “mine” is actually writing on:

In reality, it’s not very clear in the completely new whether or not we have been speaking about one or two children. If it is one to, in addition to presenter however really wants to mention both themself and you will Gregg, i then thought “Gregg’s and you may my personal boy” might be natural than just “My personal and you can Gregg’s kid”. And if there are two main – I would like “Gregg’s and you will my loved ones”, I think.

Hi porsche, I’m nevertheless not too sure

– I’m sure it’s not what you asked, but the so much more I believe about any of it, the fresh new shorter reasoning I select to mention sometimes Gregg or me personally; one another knows whoever child is involved. Whenever we present the daughter so you can someone I do not imagine we constantly say, “This is exactly Gregg’s and you can my personal child”, but either “It is the daughter” or “This will be my girl”. Subsequently, In my opinion we had be much more gonna say “my kid” otherwise “my personal girl” than “my personal child”, would not we? Or while i said before, just fool around with its label:

To the example offered from the new concern, my personal is correct and mine grammatically impossible – the others is simply concept.

– I concur that that which you state is the cure for the newest brand spanking new matter, although other people is not just regarding design, it is more about sounding sheer. I recently don’t think you to definitely “my and Gregg’s kid” is pure English. It does not sound in my experience particularly some thing an indigenous speaker do state.

Commonly, I go along with most which you told you, with the exception of one thing

Your mentioned that the first sentence is not too obvious. I disagree. All type put forth so far possess an lovoo profile examples extremely certain meaning:

can just only imply the same thing. A few would state it is ungrammatical, having “my” coming basic, however if perhaps not ungrammatical, it’s about sensed rude of the every. Which pronoun move is entirely inappropriate, even in casual message. If you speak in this way, men, “educated” or not, tend to think you are an earlier adolescent which can not set out their smartphone.

may also only mean Greg has a young child, you may have a separate man, and you will anybody took each other students to college. While this and matical, it is still impolite. Understand the review above on “my”.

Note, evey solitary one among them designs is completely unambiguous. Perhaps are grammatical, however should be stopped to own reasons stated.

History, Tend to, their feedback in regards to the must talk about Greg is extremely well drawn. Especially for cases where Greg and you’ve got a young child together with her, it would be not likely to mention Greg after all (that makes it also sharper you to “mine” meaans a couple different infants). Basic, by the discussing Greg, it’s no less than intended that he’s not in fact introduce. If it was the actual situation, why should the guy also be mentioned? You’d only state

We totally agree totally that all phrases you considering is actually unambiguous, but they have been all the outcome of our interpretation of your own original phrase. Ok, while the sbee up coming asks when it is going to be ‘my’, he does inform you, however, if we make fresh phrase because stands rather than one comment, then i still found it uncertain. We thinkl that is what I created.